Articles
Life Esidimeni deaths: Can the former MEC for health and public health officials escape liability for the deaths of the mental-health patients on the basis of obedience to ‘superior orders’ or because the officials under them were negligent?
Abstract
Arising out of the reported evidence in the Life Esidimeni Arbitration hearings into the deaths of mental patients, the question arises whether the former MEC for health, the mental health director, the head of the department of health and the project manager can use the defence of 'superior orders' to escape criminal or civil liability. The question is: Can the former MEC for health escape liability, by blaming the mental health director, the head of the department of health and the project manager for the deaths, as she did in her evidence? It is suggested that, based on the reported evidence, neither the former MEC for health nor the mental health director, the head of the department of health and the project manager can escape liability for negligently causing the deaths of the patients. They could all be prosecuted for culpable homicide, and in some instances - depending on the results of the Arbitration hearings - liable to compensate surviving mentally ill patients for physical or psychological harm, and the families of deceased patients for psychological harm.
Author's affiliations
David Jan McQuoid-Mason, University of KwaZulu-Natal
Full Text
PDF (61KB)Cite this article
Article History
Date published: 2018-07-12
Article Views
Full text views: 2677
Comments on this article
*Read our policy for posting comments hereby Dani Zulkifly (2018-07-25)
by mamat pelo (2018-07-26)
by Mr adam robbin (2018-08-06)
by jacksonjob0689 jacksonjob0689 jacksonjob0689 (2018-08-08)
by mamat pelo (2018-08-14)
by Alex Hau (2018-09-05)
"kitchen faucets s kitchenfaucets" (2018-09-06)
by mamat pelo (2018-09-06)
by mamat pelo (2018-09-06)
by Zill Zill (2018-09-22)
by larissa luna (2018-10-05)
by larissa luna (2018-10-05)
by Vanessa Vanessa Santos (2018-10-08)
by lacose lacose lacose lacose (2018-10-11)
by larissa luna (2018-10-12)
"black dog" (2018-10-12)
by Vanessa Vanessa Santos (2018-10-17)
"Mr. mona singh" (2018-10-20)
by larissa luna (2018-10-21)
"Mr david vinh" (2018-10-22)
"Mr. dolly singh" (2018-10-24)
by larissa luna (2018-10-27)
"Mr Cherryoneone cherry one" (2018-10-30)
"Mr. elisingh singh" (2018-11-01)
by larissa luna (2018-11-02)
by larissa luna (2018-11-02)
"Dr. vir singh" (2018-11-02)
"Mr. umasingh singh" (2018-11-02)
by kirito kirito (2018-11-05)
"Mr Victor Nguyen" (2018-11-06)
"xeniel xeniel xeniel" (2018-11-09)
"Mr. sanisingh singh" (2018-11-14)
by Angeleena j (2018-11-16)
"Mr. & Mrs. suny singh" (2018-11-17)
"summmit summmit summmit" (2018-11-23)
by Clinton clintonjmolina (2018-11-23)
by biel martins (2018-11-23)
by biel martins (2018-11-23)
by Công ty Mbet88w (2018-12-24)
by Ssregina Regina (2018-12-26)
by Ssregina Regina (2018-12-26)
by Ssregina Regina (2018-12-27)
by princy william (2018-12-28)
"Kellie Bandy" (2018-12-30)
by princy william (2019-01-03)
by Ssregina Regina (2019-01-03)
by Ssregina Regina (2019-01-03)
by princy william (2019-01-04)
by Ssregina Regina (2019-01-04)
by princy william (2019-01-05)
by princy william (2019-01-05)
by Ssregina Regina (2019-01-05)
by Ssregina Regina (2019-01-05)
by princy william (2019-01-08)
by princy william (2019-01-08)
by Ssregina Regina (2019-01-10)
"sir kumar" (2019-01-10)
"Lauri Haviland" (2019-01-12)
by Ssregina Regina (2019-01-21)
by Ssregina Regina (2019-01-21)
by Ssregina Regina (2019-01-21)
by Ssregina Regina (2019-01-22)
by Sheri Salisbury (2019-01-23)
by Ssregina Regina (2019-01-23)
"Rick Stainforth" (2019-01-23)
"Jaxon Schofield" (2019-01-23)
by Ssregina Regina (2019-01-28)
by Ssregina Regina (2019-01-28)
by Ssregina Regina (2019-01-29)
by Ssregina Regina (2019-01-30)
"Roseline Lynsey" (2019-01-30)
by Ssregina Regina (2019-01-31)
by Ssregina Regina (2019-01-31)
by Ssregina Regina (2019-01-31)
by Ssregina Regina (2019-02-01)
by Ssregina Regina (2019-02-01)
by Ssregina Regina (2019-02-01)
"Kilby Stanton" (2019-02-01)
by Racquel Janita (2019-02-01)
by Ssregina Regina (2019-02-02)
by Ssregina Regina (2019-02-02)
"senhor assistente de Viagem" (2019-02-02)
"Groman Nitz" (2019-02-02)
"Ritchie January" (2019-02-02)
"Rosalee Janita" (2019-02-02)
"Aquilino Siegal" (2019-02-03)
"Bird Groman" (2019-02-04)
"Holley Donald" (2019-02-04)
"Destiny Alysa" (2019-02-04)
by Ssregina Regina (2019-02-04)
"Eyman Rosalee" (2019-02-04)
"Lemon Demaris" (2019-02-04)
"Star Cory" (2019-02-04)
by Ssregina Regina (2019-02-04)
by Lasonya Kilby (2019-02-04)
"Barnes Carrera" (2019-02-04)
"Babette Donovan" (2019-02-04)
"Freyer Schechter" (2019-02-04)
"Sadie Dung" (2019-02-04)
by Eyman Vandermolen (2019-02-04)
"Fredda Azar" (2019-02-04)
"Bryant Alysa" (2019-02-04)
"Mcquiston Gale" (2019-02-04)
by Johnathan Carrera (2019-02-04)
"Edington Treva" (2019-02-04)
"Enciso Nelia" (2019-02-04)
by Kassie Lujan (2019-02-05)
by Ssregina Regina (2019-02-05)
"Disher Neal" (2019-02-05)
"Lynsey Edington" (2019-02-05)
by Ssregina Regina (2019-02-05)
"Nies Esperanza" (2019-02-05)
by Ssregina Regina (2019-02-05)
by Dematteo Annamaria (2019-02-05)
"Synthia Tammi" (2019-02-05)
by Grisel Synthia (2019-02-05)
by Neal Keith (2019-02-06)
"Bryant Carl" (2019-02-06)
"Mcquiston Shawnna" (2019-02-06)
by Ssregina Regina (2019-02-06)
"Latricia Cory" (2019-02-06)
by Lehto Kierstead (2019-02-06)
by Ssregina Regina (2019-02-06)
by Ssregina Regina (2019-02-07)
by Ssregina Regina (2019-02-07)
by Ssregina Regina (2019-02-08)
by Ssregina Regina (2019-02-09)
by Ssregina Regina (2019-02-11)
by Ssregina Regina (2019-02-11)
by Ssregina Regina (2019-02-12)
by Ssregina Regina (2019-02-12)
by Ssregina Regina (2019-02-13)
by Ssregina Regina (2019-02-13)
by Ssregina Regina (2019-02-14)
by Ssregina Regina (2019-02-14)
by Ssregina Regina (2019-02-15)
by Ssregina Regina (2019-02-15)
by Ssregina Regina (2019-02-16)
by Ssregina Regina (2019-02-16)
by Ssregina Regina (2019-02-18)
by Ssregina Regina (2019-02-19)
by Ssregina Regina (2019-02-20)
by Ssregina Regina (2019-02-20)
by Ssregina Regina (2019-02-20)
by Ssregina Regina (2019-02-21)
by Ssregina Regina (2019-02-21)
by Ssregina Regina (2019-02-22)
by Ssregina Regina (2019-02-22)
by Ssregina Regina (2019-02-23)
by Ssregina Regina (2019-02-23)
by Ssregina Regina (2019-02-23)
by Ssregina Regina (2019-02-23)
by Ssregina Regina (2019-02-25)
by Ssregina Regina (2019-02-26)
by Ssregina Regina (2019-02-26)
by Ssregina Regina (2019-02-26)
by Ssregina Regina (2019-02-27)
by Ssregina Regina (2019-02-27)
by Ssregina Regina (2019-02-27)
by Ssregina Regina (2019-02-28)
by Ssregina Regina (2019-03-01)
by Ssregina Regina (2019-03-01)
by Ssregina Regina (2019-03-01)
by Ssregina Regina (2019-03-02)
by Ssregina Regina (2019-03-02)
by Ssregina Regina (2019-03-04)
by Ssregina Regina (2019-03-04)
by Ssregina Regina (2019-03-05)
by Ssregina Regina (2019-03-05)
by Ssregina Regina (2019-03-06)
by Ssregina Regina (2019-03-06)
by Ssregina Regina (2019-03-06)
by Ssregina Regina (2019-03-07)
by Ssregina Regina (2019-03-08)
by Ssregina Regina (2019-03-09)